You would think that as father of openly gay physician Dr. Peter Shalit, author of "Living Well, the Gay Man's Essential Health Guide," Gene Shalit's review of "Brokeback Mountain" would have been a little less misguided. Mr. Shalit is one of the few film critics that I usually agree with.
Calling Jack a "sexual predator" in no way describes the relationship I watched. There was a very brief hesitation on the part of Heath Ledger's character Ennis, but the consummation of the relationship was something done between equals.
By making the first move does that the character of Jack a sexual predator?
If the answer to that question is yes, then I guess most of us could be called a sexual predator during some point of our lives. I have made the first move on more than one occasion with someone that I wasn't sure would return, for a lack of better words, the interest I felt in them.
Being less sensitive than GLAAD, I wouldn't really call the remarks as anti-gay or prejudiced. I would, however, say that Mr. Shalit could have made a different choice of words. Jack instigated the relationship, but Ennis was far from being a victim. In actually reading Brokeback Mountain, it is clear that Ennis loved Jack, and felt the same need to continually meet with Jack in order to reaffirm their love and passion for each other.
Shame on you Mr. Shalit, for misleading the movie going public into thinking that the relationship between Jack and Ennis was something other than the love story it was meant to be viewed as.
Recent Comments